Raiders’ Qb Dilemma: Cousins or Mendoza?

Kubiak Weighs Veteran vs. Rookie Options

The Las Vegas Raiders enter training camp with a quarterback room that feels unsettled. Head coach Klint Kubiak must decide whether to keep veteran Kirk Cousins in the starting role or give the No. 1 overall pick, Fernando Mendoza, an immediate shot. The choice could shape the offense’s tempo and influence how the rookie handles the spotlight. Whether the plan leans toward watching from the sidelines or stepping onto the field remains a mystery.

Marcus Allen, a former Raider, suspects the team has a nuanced plan for Mendoza. “I don’t have any idea what their plan is,” Allen said on NFL Network, noting he’s heard the rookie might sit and watch, or he could be thrust into action. “Personally, I don’t mind younger players sitting, watching and learning.” Allen’s comments underscore a cautious approach that many GMs favor when handling top picks. His trust in general manager John Spytek suggests the Raiders may prioritize a measured rollout.

The uncertainty follows a sterling college season for Mendoza. While at Indiana, he logged 724 snaps and earned an 87.9 overall PFF grade. His 2,758 passing yards and 32 touchdowns contrasted with five interceptions, complemented by 16 big‑time throws and nine turnover‑worthy plays. On the ground, he added 200 scramble yards and six rushing touchdowns, painting a picture of a dual‑threat signal‑caller.

Mendoza’s College Stats Signal Pro Potential

Mendoza’s statistical résumé from the Hoosiers highlights his readiness and upside. The 724 snaps he played indicate consistent involvement, while the 87.9 PFF grade places him among the elite college quarterbacks. His passing yardage and touchdown total dwarf many peers, and the six rushing touchdowns show versatility that NFL defenses must account for. These numbers give the Raiders confidence, but also remind them of the pressure that accompanies the No. 1 pick.

Behind the scenes, the NFL community is watching how the Raiders handle this infusion of talent. The league often debates whether top‑rafted quarterbacks should be thrown into the fire or groomed slowly. Mendoza’s blend of arm talent, mobility, and poise could accelerate his development, but only if the organization balances his growth with realistic expectations. The Raiders’ decision will likely serve as a case study for how other teams manage their franchise QBs.

Allen’s Caution and Crosby’s Advice

Marcus Allen warned that the financial stakes and fame that accompany a top pick can lead to rushed decisions. “The pressure and expectation…means we often throw players out there when they may not be ready,” he noted. Despite the hype, Allen expressed confidence in Spytek’s ability to navigate the situation. His faith suggests the Raiders may avoid a precipitous move and instead focus on building around the rookie.

Maxx Crosby, a veteran defensive end, delivered a blunt message to Mendoza about authenticity. During a July 7 broadcast of “The Rush With Maxx Crosby,” he told the rookie to stay genuine. “If you’re not genuine, guys pick up on that real quick because college is different,” Crosby explained. He reminded Mendoza that professional life brings different motivations, families, and expectations. Crosby added that being real never fails, and he’s “off the wall” himself, implying that authenticity trumps pretension. This counsel could help Mendoza earn the trust of seasoned teammates and settle into his new role quickly.