Trade Talk Swirls Around Injured Colts QB Anthony Richardson

Season of Setbacks: Richardson’s Injury History

Anthony Richardson entered the league as the fourth overall pick in the 2023 draft and is now approaching his fourth season. A concussion in Week 2 and a shoulder injury in Week 5 ended his rookie year. In 2024 he missed time with a hip problem in Week 4 and a back and foot issue in Week 16, and a pre‑game resistance‑band mishap in 2025 shattered an orbital bone, sidelining him for the remainder of that season. The recurring injuries have limited him to just 17 NFL games across four years and forced the Colts to consider his long‑term role on the roster.

On‑field Numbers: A Mixed Bag Over Four Seasons

Richardson’s passing statistics show a steep decline since his debut season. He completed 59.5 % of his throws in 2023, throwing for three touchdowns and one interception while also adding four rushing scores. The following year his completion rate fell to 47.7 %, with eight passing touchdowns offset by a league‑high 12 interceptions; he also contributed six rushing touchdowns. In the truncated 2025 campaign he appeared in just two games, leaving his statistical line incomplete. The erratic production has made evaluators wary of his draft value, often describing it as a mid‑ to late‑round asset.

Contract and Roster Impact

Spotrac reports that Richardson’s contract counts $10.8 million against the Colts’ 2026 salary cap, a significant commitment for a player who has yet to establish himself as a starter. He is currently vying with rookie Riley Leonard for the backup quarterback spot, though the recent Achilles‑injury recovery of former starter Daniel Jones adds another layer of competition. Jones was instrumental in a 7‑1 run to open 2025, posting a 68.0 % completion rate with 19 passing touchdowns and eight interceptions before missing the final games of the season. The Colts remain optimistic that Jones can be ready for the season‑opening contest, which could reshape the backup battle.

Potential Landing Spots According to Analysts

Bleacher Report’s Brad Gagnon believes Richardson could be on the move when training camp opens. He lists the Cardinals as a primary destination, especially if Jacoby Brissett’s contract dispute escalates. The Jets are also mentioned, should Geno Smith fail to meet expectations after his return to the NFL. Meanwhile, the Steelers, Cowboys, and Panthers are viewed as possible “stash‑away” options for 2027, where Richardson could develop without the pressure of immediate contribution. Brissett, a former Colt, is currently demanding more than $1.5 million guaranteed for 2026 and may miss camp, while Gardner Minshew remains a journeyman with 47 career starts who could be called upon if other plans fall through.

Colts’ Quarterback Landscape

The Colts’ current depth chart is a tapestry of familiar faces and emerging talent. All of Arizona’s quarterbacks have spent time with Indianapolis, highlighting the franchise’s willingness to evaluate options. Jacoby Brissett, the likely starter, wants significant guaranteed money and his training‑camp status is uncertain. Gardner Minshew, who has started 47 games across his career, could be pressed into service if Brissett’s situation deteriorates. Meanwhile, the Jets have added veteran Geno Smith, who counts $3.3 million against the cap, and drafted Cade Klubnik in the fourth round of the 2026 draft. The Steelers have reunited Aaron Rodgers with coach Mike McCarthy, while the Panthers continue to develop Bryce Young despite never finishing a season above .500.

Looking Ahead: What It Means for Fans and Fantasy

For fans, Richardson’s uncertain future adds intrigue to the Colts’ rebuilding narrative, especially with the team’s high cap investment in a quarterback who has yet to prove his health or effectiveness. Fantasy owners should watch the competition between Richardson, Leonard, and Jones, as any health issue could swing back‑up duties quickly. The broader NFL market will be watching Brad Gagnon’s predictions, as each potential trade could reshape the roster dynamics of the Cardinals, Jets, Steelers, Cowboys, and Panthers. The coming season will decide whether Richardson’s damaged arm and inconsistent play are enough to keep him in Indianapolis or if he’ll find a new home where he can rebuild his career.