Sanders’ 2025 Slump and 2026 Browns QB Hope

Why the Browns Are Looking at a New Quarterback

The Cleveland Browns are again searching for answers at the quarterback spot, hoping to fix a position that has seen frequent turnover. Veteran Deshaun Watson is back, attempting to recapture the magic that once defined his Houston days. Meanwhile, second‑year pro Shedeur Sanders is still trying to recover from a disastrous rookie season. The competition and expectations are high as the team moves toward a pivotal 2026 campaign.

Shedeur Sanders’ Rough 2025 Campaign

Shedeur Sanders finished 2025 as the NFL’s worst starting quarterback according to SB Nation’s analytics rankings. The system scores categories out of five, with five being average, and Sanders posted scores above that mark only in offensive impact and clutch performance. In the other four areas—accuracy, explosive plays, scoring, and turnover avoidance—he fell well below the neutral line. The data paints a stark picture of a season many consider one of the poorest for a starter in recent memory.

Offseason Changes and Trade Buzz

Sanders claims to have progressed significantly during the latest offseason, a sentiment echoed by the coaching staff. Yet the same period has also been marked by trade rumors linking him to other franchises, suggesting the stakes are high for both the player and the Browns. The quarterback also faced a public style‑versus‑substance dialogue with former teammate Joe Flacco, who challenged him to prioritize results over flash. These off‑field dynamics add another layer to his already challenging path back to form.

Comparing Sanders to Deshaun Watson’s Return

Deshaun Watson is hoping to revive the form that made him a Pro Bowl signal‑caller during his Houston tenure, a narrative that parallels Sanders’ own quest for redemption. Both players bring different skill sets: Watson offers veteran poise and a proven ability to lead a complex offense, while Sanders brings arm talent and a younger upside. Their rivalry for the starting job will likely shape the Browns’ offensive identity heading into next season. The contrast between a seasoned comeback story and a young prospect trying to overcome a bad rookie year will be a key story line.

What Lies Ahead for 2026

If Sanders can replicate the offensive impact and clutch poise that earned him marks above five, he could lock down the starting role and become the foundation of the Browns’ rebuilding effort. Conversely, continued sub‑average numbers could see the door opened for Watson to reclaim the helm or for a new signal‑caller to be brought in via trade. The Browns’ front office now faces a decision that could define the franchise’s direction for the next few years. Fans will be watching closely to see which path the quarterback competition takes.