Top 15 Softball Hitting Performances of the 2025‑26 Season

The Martin Dentistry Athlete of the Week series is moving into its summer recap, spotlighting the most memorable single‑game offensive displays from the 2025‑26 high‑school softball campaign. After readers voted on baseball’s best hitting feats, the focus now turns to the girls’ performers, with a poll open until noon on Thursday, July 23. This roundup highlights the standout games that defined the season and their impact on postseason races and college recruiting.

Why the Poll Matters This Summer

Each year, the Athlete of the Week poll gives fans a chance to crown the hottest hitter before the offseason gets into full swing. The voting period runs without restriction, encouraging multiple submissions and spirited debate among local softball circles. As the season winds down, the results help shape the narrative around individual achievements and team momentum heading into the CIF playoffs. The final rankings will also feed into the broader Martin Dentistry honors later this year.

standout Performances

• Mackenzie Coffman (Mountain House) – 3‑for‑4, three‑run homer, six RBIs on opening day loss to Kimball (Feb. 12). The senior’s all‑or‑nothing effort set a high bar for the season’s first games.
• Jamaiya Wilson (Edison) – Four walks, RBI double, 34‑season RBIs total; debut vs. Grant (Feb. 19). The freshman’s mature approach signaled early promise for college scouts.
• Lelia Tatupu (Edison) – 4‑for‑5, two triples, HR, seven RBIs vs. Sonora (Feb. 28). Her 24‑run demolition highlighted Edison’s offensive dominance.
• Emalee Cargill (Tracy) – 3‑for‑3, HR, six RBIs vs. No. 39 Central Catholic (Mar. 5). The Cal signee delivered against a top‑40 California team.
• Angelina Martinez (Ripon) – 2‑for‑3, HR, five RBIs vs. Livingston (Mar. 7). Showed she can impact the game beyond pitching duties.
• Taylor Sansaver (Tracy) – 4‑for‑4, rare hitting cycle, five RBIs vs. Lodi (Mar. 19). The Arizona commit became one of the few to complete the cycle that season.
• Shayla Shanks (Bear Creek) – 3‑for‑6, five RBIs all via singles vs. Stagg (Apr. 2). Proved big offensive nights don’t always need extra‑base hits.
• Julieann Drulias (BHCPA) – 6‑for‑6, five RBIs with a single, double, triple, HR vs. ALHA (Apr. 8). The Jackson State signee paced her team to a 26‑5 win.
• Octavia Orndoff (River Island) – 5‑for‑5, three HRs, double, triple, 13 RBIs vs. ALHA (Apr. 29). Her near‑cycle performance was one of the season’s most explosive.
• Katie Schallberger (Linden) – 3‑for‑6, HR, eight RBIs in a 34‑run slugfest vs. Riverbank (Apr. 30). The senior’s eight‑RBI day stood out even in a wild 22‑12 win.
• Na’ima Calderon (Manteca) – 3‑for‑4, two HRs, six RBIs vs. Mountain House (May 4). The junior helped Manteca finish the VOL schedule strongly.
• Taylor Sansaver (Tracy) – 3‑for‑5, six RBIs vs. Kimball (May 6). The junior sealed a third mercy‑rule shutout of Kimball in TCAL play.
• Bella Granata (Liberty Ranch) – 4‑for‑4, HR, six RBIs vs. No. 13 Woodland Christian (May 13). The senior signee led No. 4 Liberty Ranch to an 18‑0 playoff opener.
• Olivia Fears (Linden) – 5‑for‑5, HR, triple, four RBIs vs. No. 6 Bear River (May 15). The Pacific signee turned a perfect 4‑for‑4 into another massive outing.
• Madison Babasa (Escalon) – 4‑for‑4, two doubles, triple, three RBIs vs. No. 5 Casa Roble (May 23). The Arizona signee sparked a 16‑win squad to its sixth CIF Section title.

These performances not only set statistical benchmarks but also propelled their teams into postseason berths and national attention. College recruiters will be watching closely, especially the players signed to programs like Arizona, Jackson State, San Diego State, and the University of the Pacific. As the poll votes roll in, the final verdict will reflect which game truly captured the essence of the 2025‑26 season’s offensive fireworks. Keep voting until July 23 to decide who claims the top honor.

The image below provides a backdrop for the Athlete of the Week series, featuring the Martin Dentistry logo.

With the season’s best moments compiled, fans can look forward to more offseason coverage, including interviews with top performers and a look ahead at what next year may hold for San Joaquin County softball.