Arizona Cardinals Offseason D- Versus the Field

Offseason Grade Lands a D-

Matt Okada from NFL.com handed the Cardinals a D-minus for their recent roster moves. The lowest mark was driven by the decision to draft a running back after a dismal 3‑14 campaign. The analyst argued that such picks rarely provide the kind of impact needed by a rebuilding franchise.

Major Roster Changes

Kyler Murray was let go, leaving Arizona’s backfield to fend for itself. The team now leans on 24‑year‑old rookie Carson Beck, supplemented by veterans Jacoby Brissett and Gardner Minshew. In free agency, the Cardinals signed guard Seumalo as their standout acquisition.

Draft Picks and Values

Arizona selected OG Chase Bisontis with the 34th overall pick and DT Kaleb Proctor at 104th overall, both of which could become modest bargains if they develop. The draft also featured a running back known as Love, who is praised for his talent but carries the typical risk associated with the position. The critique noted that Saquon Barkley, taken second overall by the Giants, never helped his team win a division title during his six seasons.

Quarterback Situation Remains Cloudy

After moving on from Murray, the Cardinals are counting on three options: Beck, Brissett and Minshew. This lack of a definitive starter adds uncertainty heading into 2026. Observers say the roster still lacks a clear answer at the most critical position.

Pass Rush Largely Untouched

Despite ranking as a potential weakness, Arizona added no notable pass‑rushing talent. The only mention of a defensive prospect is Arvell Reese, who may not fit the traditional edge‑rusher role. Consequently, the pass rush continues to be an area of concern for the defense.

Skill‑Player Additions and Depth

Cardinals bolstered their receiving corps and added depth elsewhere on the offensive side. While those skill‑players are solid, the overall impact is limited without a reliable pass protector and a hardened defense. The team’s chances for a winning season now hinge on whether the new pieces can offset the glaring gaps.

What Lies Ahead

Fan sentiment views the offseason as a missed opportunity to address core problems. Success will depend on the growth of Beck and the development of the rookie draft picks. The D‑ grade serves as a clear signal that the Cardinals still have work to do before they can compete for a playoff spot.