Why ESPN Analyst Picks Daniels Over Maye And Williams

ESPN Rankings Spark Debate

ESPN analyst Louis Riddick declared Jayden Daniels the best quarterback of the 2024 NFL Draft class, a view that divides fans of other top signal‑callers like Drake Maye and Caleb Williams. Riddick’s comment came after ESPN released its latest top‑10 quarterback rankings, which placed Maye at No. 8 and Williams at No. 10 while leaving Daniels off the list. The rankings draw from votes of NFL executives, coaches, and scouts, giving them added credibility in the evaluation of talent.

Riddick’s Social‑Media Take

On X, Riddick wrote, “Jayden Daniels is still the best QB of the ‘24 class so…,” sparking a heated discussion among analysts and fans. The outspoken opinion highlights a split between those who trust early‑season statistics and those who prioritize volume and durability. While Maye and Williams have higher rankings, Riddick argues that Daniels still leads the 2024 class.

Daniels’ Rookie Resume

Daniels earned his reputation by leading the Washington Commanders to the NFC Championship Game as a rookie. Despite missing all but seven games because of injury, he still amassed 1,262 passing yards with eight touchdowns and three interceptions. The No. 2 overall pick’s health setbacks remain the biggest concern for teams evaluating his long‑term potential.

Maye’s MVP‑Level Season

Drake Maye turned heads with a season that earned him a runner‑up finish in the 2025 NFL MVP voting. The Patriots quarterback threw for 4,394 yards, 31 touchdowns and 10 interceptions, surpassing even Daniels’ rookie numbers. Maye’s ability to keep New England in the playoffs, culminating in a trip to the Super Bowl, makes him a strong contender for the top spot.

Williams’ Playoff Push

Caleb Williams delivered a solid campaign for the Chicago Bears, guiding the team to the divisional round of the playoffs. The former No. 1 overall pick posted 3,942 yards, 27 touchdowns and seven interceptions, proving he remains competitive at the highest level. Bears fans point to these stats as evidence that Daniels is not the undisputed best of the 2024 class.

What The Debate Tells Us

The back‑and‑forth over who tops the 2024 quarterback class shows how injury history can influence perception. Daniels displayed elite play when healthy but missed significant time, limiting his statistical resume. Maye and Williams, by contrast, logged full seasons and accumulated impressive yardage and touchdown totals, leading many to question Riddick’s bold claim.

As the 2024 class continues to develop, scouts and coaches will watch each player’s durability and growth. The conversation will likely evolve as new data emerges, but for now, the discussion fuels interest in what the future holds for these promising quarterbacks.