Tim Murnane and the 1917 All-Star Game

The Real Origin of baseball’s First All-Star Contest

Scott Reich’s new release, “One Day in September,” reshapes conventional history by arguing that the inaugural All‑Star Game took place in 1917, not the commonly cited 1933. The contest was organized as a charity exhibition in honor of Tim Murnane, a figure with deep roots in Philadelphia baseball. According to the author, the event predated the modern All‑Star concept by more than a decade, serving a purpose far beyond pure competition. Reich positions the game as an early example of how sports can rally communities around a shared cause.

Who Was Tim Murnane?

Tim Murnane began his playing career with the Philadelphia Athletics before moving to other clubs, later transitioning into scouting and managing responsibilities. He became a respected voice at the Boston Globe, where his columns earned him trust among owners, players, and readers alike. Reich highlights Murnane’s push for reforms aimed at making the sport more equitable and competitive. His sudden death from a heart attack in February 1917 left a widow, six children, and limited financial security.

Stars Came Together for a Cause

When news of Murnane’s plight spread, legendary figures such as Ty Cobb, Shoeless Joe Jackson, and Philadelphia manager Connie Mack organized a benefit game. The athletes purchased their own train tickets, traveling overnight at personal expense to support the grieving family. The event was held at Fenway Park, where the crowd’s generosity covered the cost of a house and more. Their collective effort underscored a belief that professional athletes could use their platform to help those in need.

The Legacy of a United Effort

Reich notes that the gathering illustrated the unifying power of sport, a theme that resonates even in today’s fragmented society. He recalls a reflection on standing shoulder to shoulder, cheering for a common purpose, and deciding to care for one another. The episode remains a rare historical footnote that proves athletics can transcend rivalry for a higher humanitarian goal. The story’s echo persists, reminding modern fans of the potential for community building through shared experience.

Find Out More

To read the full narrative behind this forgotten milestone and uncover additional anecdotes about the 1917 contest, CLICK HERE for access to Scott Reich’s book “One Day in September.”