2026 NFL: Nate Tice & Matt Harmon Name the Most Average Players by Position

Defining “Average” in Today’s NFL

In a new podcast episode, analysts Nate Tice and Matt Harmon lay out what they consider “average” for an NFL player. They argue that average performers often provide dependable, low‑risk contributions that can be more valuable than star talent when building a balanced roster. The conversation sets the stage for a position‑by‑position look at the most routine‑looking players heading into the 2026 season.

Skill Players: QBs, RBs, WRs and TEs

The duo spotlights the most average skill players, including an Arizona Cardinals quarterback embroiled in a contract dispute and a tight end who repeats his status from last year’s list. These players, while not elite, are expected to fill essential roles without overwhelming expectations. The analysis also touches on the impact of average backs and receivers in modern offensive schemes.

College QBs to Watch This Fall

Podcast guest Eric Froton, a college fantasy analyst, introduces Yahoo’s fresh college fantasy product. He highlights three quarterbacks he’s eager to monitor: LSU’s Sam Leavitt, California’s Jaron‑Keawe Sagapolutele and Ohio State’s Julian Sayin. Froton explains why these players could disrupt projections and offers a preview of what fantasy managers might see in the upcoming season.

Offensive Line: The Unsung Workhorses

At the 59‑minute mark, Tice and Harmon shift focus to offensive linemen—offensive tackles, guards and centers. They identify the most average players at these positions, emphasizing how consistent, journeyman linemen can stabilize a unit that often hides behind the star quarterback. The discussion also evaluates how these linemen might influence overall team efficiency.

Defensive Stars (or Lack Thereof)

The final segment breaks down the most average defenders, covering cornerbacks, safeties, linebackers, defensive tackles and defensive ends. The analysts point out that many of these players are overlooked but can still deliver solid, average performances that swing win probabilities. They also speculate on how roster construction may prioritize depth at these spots.

How Many Wins Will These Rookies Bring?

Throughout the episode, Tice and Harmon ponder the win‑impact of assembling a roster built around average talent. They suggest that while average players may not dazzle, their combined reliability can translate into a baseline number of victories—potentially enough to make a playoff push in a competitive conference. Listeners are left with a framework for evaluating roster construction beyond blockbuster signings.

The conversation wraps up with a reminder that the 2026 season will test whether the average label holds true under the pressure of a full schedule, and how fantasy managers can balance risk and reward when drafting players who often fly under the radar.